Compare car insurance rates for November 2022

Why comparison shopping matters for auto insurance

Buying car insurance doesn’t need to be complicated — remember that comparing quotes from at least a few companies means you'll be able to find the best deal. Policygenius can help you compare auto insurance quotes and find coverage that meets your needs, at a price that works for you.

We’ve saved customers an average of 19% a year on auto insurance

Your car insurance rates are based on things like your age, where you live, and what kind of car you drive. But not all auto insurance companies charge the same rates, so comparing car insurance quotes before you buy a policy can help you save money.

Compare car insurance rates by age and gender

Your age and gender can also have an impact on your car insurance rates. Young and inexperienced drivers often face much higher costs than older drivers. That’s why it’s even more important for young drivers to compare rates before buying car insurance. 

Men sometimes pay slightly more for car insurance than women — although some states have passed laws banning insurance companies from using gender to determine rates.

Company	16-year-old female	16-year-old male	18-year-old female	18-year-old male	21-year-old female	21-year-old male	25-year-old female	25-year-old male	30-year-old female	30-year-old male	35-year-old female	35-year-old male	45-year-old female	45-year-old male	55-year-old female	55-year-old male
Allstate	$8,215	$8,788	$5,015	$5,916	$2,746	$3,134	$2,155	$2,222	$2,012	$1,999	$1,984	$1,971	$1,967	$1,954	$1,819	$1,860
American Family	$4,323	$4,721	$3,059	$3,320	$2,076	$2,227	$1,510	$1,592	$1,457	$1,515	$1,404	$1,452	$1,315	$1,344	$1,260	$1,274
Erie	$2,705	$3,584	$2,357	$2,968	$1,750	$2,170	$1,356	$1,354	$1,224	$1,200	$1,150	$1,127	$1,050	$1,043	$988	$1,004
Farmers	$10,164	$10,812	$7,682	$8,155	$2,655	$2,907	$2,106	$2,201	$1,997	$1,997	$1,958	$1,909	$1,960	$1,844	$1,721	$1,699
GEICO	$4,341	$4,803	$2,911	$3,182	$1,742	$1,825	$1,321	$1,346	$1,197	$1,179	$1,203	$1,174	$1,188	$1,163	$1,105	$1,064
Nationwide	$5,099	$6,111	$4,427	$5,328	$2,279	$2,557	$1,670	$1,784	$1,511	$1,530	$1,492	$1,497	$1,401	$1,410	$1,274	$1,294
Progressive	$9,478	$10,343	$7,138	$7,942	$2,708	$3,054	$1,941	$1,958	$1,861	$1,810	$1,836	$1,752	$1,728	$1,654	$1,509	$1,503
State Farm	$3,422	$4,222	$2,718	$3,327	$1,849	$2,189	$1,298	$1,437	$1,194	$1,194	$1,170	$1,170	$1,155	$1,155	$1,093	$1,093
Travelers	$6,408	$8,022	$3,686	$4,487	$2,143	$2,450	$1,602	$1,658	$1,539	$1,590	$1,515	$1,555	$1,398	$1,433	$1,265	$1,305
USAA	$4,414	$4,792	$2,659	$2,860	$1,506	$1,617	$1,224	$1,286	$1,081	$1,102	$1,037	$1,051	$975	$988	$930	$943

Collapse table

→ Learn more about rates by age and gender

Compare car insurance rates for seniors

Comparing car insurance quotes and shopping around is also important for senior drivers. After around 65 or 70, car insurance rates for older drivers may start going up. For retired seniors who are on a fixed income, comparing costs is an easy way to avoid overpaying.

Our analysis shows that a 70-year-old driver can pay as much as $2,057 per year for car insurance with some companies. But with others, rates may be as low as $1,037 per year — a difference of more than half.

Company	60-year-old female	60-year-old male	65-year-old female	65-year-old male	70-year-old female	70-year-old male
Allstate	$1,815	$1,856	$1,892	$1,935	$1,916	$1,959
American Family	$1,259	$1,266	$1,293	$1,292	$1,383	$1,372
Erie	$1,013	$1,032	$1,057	$1,086	$1,123	$1,153
Farmers	$1,662	$1,685	$1,800	$1,875	$1,909	$2,057
GEICO	$1,098	$1,067	$1,093	$1,073	$1,157	$1,143
Nationwide	$1,250	$1,265	$1,277	$1,319	$1,354	$1,434
Progressive	$1,508	$1,507	$1,550	$1,583	$1,666	$1,705
State Farm	$1,068	$1,068	$1,064	$1,064	$1,107	$1,107
Travelers	$1,270	$1,321	$1,321	$1,388	$1,401	$1,500
USAA	$924	$939	$945	$964	$1,005	$1,037

Collapse table

→ Learn more about car insurance for senior drivers

Compare car insurance rates by state

Car insurance rates vary by state, city, and even ZIP codes. That’s why comparing rates can help you find the cheapest company in your area.

Even if car insurance is normally expensive in your state, you can still save thousands of dollars a year by comparing rates. Some companies in your area may charge much less for coverage than others. 

For example, the difference between the most expensive and cheapest insurance company in Florida — known for high auto insurance rates — is a massive $2,444 per year.

State	Cheapest company	Average cost
Alabama	GEICO	$977
Alaska	USAA	$930
Arizona	Root	$747
Arkansas	USAA	$962
California	Wawanesa	$1,110
Colorado	American National	$811
Connecticut	GEICO	$756
Delaware	State Farm	$1,152
District of Columbia	GEICO	$1,025
Florida	GEICO	$1,432
Georgia	Auto-Owners Insurance	$858
Hawaii	GEICO	$785
Idaho	American National	$498
Illinois	FAIA	$712
Indiana	USAA	$706
Iowa	State Farm	$719
Kansas	USAA	$912
Kentucky	GEICO	$1,019
Louisiana	USAA	$1,486
Maine	GEICO	$571
Maryland	USAA	$806
Massachusetts	GEICO	$1,067
Michigan	GEICO	$1,059
Minnesota	Western Agriculture	$964
Mississippi	USAA	$856
Missouri	USAA	$741
Montana	USAA	$856
Nebraska	Auto-Owners Insurance	$1,036
Nevada	GEICO	$1,043
New Hampshire	USAA	$676
New Jersey	GEICO	$1,078
New Mexico	USAA	$907
New York	Main Street America	$1,033
North Carolina	GEICO	$736
North Dakota	USAA	$786
Ohio	USAA	$711
Oklahoma	USAA	$949
Oregon	State Farm	$843
Pennsylvania	Erie	$1,018
Rhode Island	State Farm	$983
South Carolina	American National	$683
South Dakota	Kemper	$1,128
Tennessee	State Farm	$755
Texas	Texas Farm Bureau	$1,036
Utah	GEICO	$856
Vermont	State Farm	$666
Virginia	USAA	$776
Washington	USAA	$1,033
West Virginia	USAA	$869
Wisconsin	USAA	$680
Wyoming	American National	$763

Collapse table

Some carriers may be represented by affiliates or subsidiaries.

→ Learn more about car insurance costs

Compare car insurance rates by credit score

If your credit score is below average or poor — or if you don’t have any credit at all — it’s even more important to compare car insurance quotes before you buy. 

Just like drivers with an accident or DUI on their records, drivers with poor credit (a credit score under 577) are also likely to pay much higher car insurance rates. Shopping around can help you find the most affordable car insurance out there, even if you have bad credit.

Company	Poor credit	Fair credit	Good credit	Very good credit	Excellent credit
Allstate	$3,335	$2,365	$2,007	$1,903	$1,706
American Family	$2,206	$1,543	$1,321	$1,219	$1,101
Erie	$2,836	$1,630	$1,200	$1,056	$955
Farmers	$3,086	$2,276	$1,973	$1,801	$1,620
GEICO	$2,219	$1,513	$1,185	$1,065	$940
Nationwide	$2,205	$1,802	$1,511	$1,431	$1,331
Progressive	$3,220	$2,254	$1,807	$1,584	$1,380
State Farm	$3,338	$1,843	$1,395	$1,224	$1,095
Travelers	$2,880	$1,975	$1,537	$1,338	$1,226
USAA	$2,018	$1,302	$1,108	$1,038	$966

Collapse table

→ Learn more about how credit scores affect car insurance rates

Compare car insurance rates by driving record

Car insurance is more expensive for drivers who have a recent at-fault accident or ticket on their records. While the average car insurance rate for drivers with a clean record is $1,652, insurance for high-risk drivers can cost $1,500 more per year.

All drivers with a recent violation on their record, like an at-fault accident or citation, should compare car insurance quotes to save money, but drivers with serious violations — like a DUI or hit-and-run — stand to save the most.

Company	Speeding ticket	At-fault accident	Suspended license	DUI
Allstate	$2,350	$3,080	$2,964	$3,047
American Family	$1,888	$2,131	$2,390	$2,083
Erie	$1,344	$1,542	$1,901	$2,032
Farmers	$2,571	$2,787	$3,046	$2,733
GEICO	$2,113	$2,063	$2,184	$3,044
Nationwide	$1,935	$2,461	$3,228	$3,298
Progressive	$2,316	$2,848	$2,692	$2,273
State Farm	$1,370	$1,445	$1,607	$1,652
Travelers	$2,283	$2,132	$2,405	$2,371
USAA	$1,329	$1,533	$1,965	$2,103

Collapse table

→ Learn more about how an accident affects your car insurance rates

Compare car insurance rates by marital status

Car insurance rates are usually slightly lower if you’re married — it’s just one of the many details that car insurance companies use to figure out how much of a risk you’ll be to insure.

We found that married drivers pay $130 less per year for car insurance, on average, than single drivers.

Company	Single	Married	Divorced
Allstate	$1,991	$1,923	$1,991
American Family	$1,515	$1,344	$1,515
Erie	$1,157	$1,081	$1,157
Farmers	$1,968	$1,811	$1,968
GEICO	$1,179	$1,210	$1,226
Nationwide	$1,569	$1,433	$1,569
Progressive	$1,814	$1,521	$1,814
State Farm	$1,808	$1,598	$1,808
Travelers	$1,586	$1,578	$1,586
USAA	$1,128	$1,008	$1,128

Collapse table

→ Learn more about car insurance for married couples

Compare car insurance rates by vehicle

The kind of car you drive also has an impact on what you’ll pay for car insurance. More expensive cars generally cost more to insure, but a safer car with updated technology that helps avoid accidents will cost less to insure than one prone to rollovers.

Company	Chevrolet Equinox	Chevrolet Silverado	Ford Escape	Ford Explorer	Ford F-150	GMC Sierra	Honda Accord	Honda Civic	Honda CR-V	Jeep Grand Cherokee	Jeep Wrangler	Nissan Rogue	Ram 1500	Subaru Forester	Subaru Outback	Toyota Camry	Toyota Corolla	Toyota Highlander	Toyota RAV4	Toyota Tacoma
Allstate	$2,164	$2,093	$2,214	$2,300	$1,952	$2,266	$2,360	$2,428	$2,085	$2,138	$2,652	$2,122	$2,557	$2,203	$2,327	$2,400	$2,267	$2,271	$2,343	$2,089
American Family	$1,490	$1,519	$1,452	$1,460	$1,420	$1,490	$1,670	$1,698	$1,533	$1,473	$1,433	$1,639	$1,545	$1,570	$1,548	$1,667	$1,756	$1,571	$1,648	$1,570
Erie	$1,210	$1,076	$1,179	$1,267	$1,014	$1,118	$1,403	$1,332	$1,124	$1,336	$1,394	$1,272	$1,200	$1,090	$1,045	$1,360	$1,440	$1,244	$1,309	$1,248
Farmers	$2,133	$2,387	$1,977	$1,920	$1,795	$1,975	$2,117	$2,483	$1,948	$2,101	$1,736	$2,192	$2,468	$2,253	$1,937	$2,260	$2,355	$2,164	$2,050	$2,119
GEICO	$1,161	$1,344	$1,219	$1,324	$1,188	$1,195	$1,341	$1,149	$1,052	$1,294	$1,126	$1,149	$1,303	$1,039	$1,061	$1,256	$1,178	$1,179	$1,154	$1,093
Nationwide	$1,377	$1,242	$1,320	$1,408	$1,276	$1,461	$1,406	$1,595	$1,257	$1,432	$1,634	$1,482	$1,616	$1,285	$1,123	$1,561	$1,704	$1,365	$1,465	$1,314
Progressive	$1,724	$1,982	$1,595	$1,806	$1,769	$1,638	$2,200	$1,675	$1,595	$1,798	$1,667	$1,731	$1,816	$1,955	$1,945	$2,047	$2,043	$1,746	$1,686	$1,695
State Farm	$1,229	$1,264	$1,234	$1,247	$1,202	$1,360	$1,418	$1,311	$1,128	$1,249	$1,404	$1,231	$1,344	$1,260	$1,316	$1,309	$1,208	$1,331	$1,424	$1,280
Travelers	$1,567	$1,560	$1,394	$1,657	$1,457	$1,450	$1,582	$1,741	$1,295	$1,533	$1,404	$1,607	$1,602	$1,339	$1,321	$1,634	$1,644	$1,508	$1,575	$1,425
USAA	$1,124	$1,225	$1,126	$1,309	$1,086	$1,235	$1,335	$1,203	$1,144	$1,246	$1,062	$1,207	$1,247	$1,123	$1,118	$1,245	$1,300	$1,166	$1,158	$1,071

Collapse table

→ Learn more about how the kind of car you drive affects insurance

Compare car insurance rates by coverage amount

Whether you want a full-coverage policy with comprehensive and collision coverage, or you just want enough insurance to meet your state’s minimum requirements, the best way to avoid paying too much for car insurance is by comparing rates to see what you’ll pay for different amounts of car insurance coverage.

Company	State minimum	50/100/50 liability	100/300/100 liability
Allstate	$750	$1,991	$2,097
American Family	$676	$1,515	$1,557
Erie	$370	$1,157	$1,201
Farmers	$781	$1,968	$2,109
GEICO	$402	$1,179	$1,261
Nationwide	$624	$1,569	$1,671
Progressive	$737	$1,814	$1,967
State Farm	$475	$1,240	$1,333
Travelers	$683	$1,586	$1,690
USAA	$369	$1,128	$1,191

Collapse table

→ Learn more about how much car insurance coverage you need

Compare the top auto insurance companies

The best auto insurance companies combine affordable coverage with highly-rated customer service and claims handling. You want to find a car insurance company that will actually be there for you when you need to use your coverage. 

Company	Policygenius rating	Average annual cost
GEICO	4.4 out of 5 stars ★	$1,187
Travelers	4.3 out of 5 stars ★	$1,580
Amica	4.2 out of 5 stars ★	$1,687
Nationwide	4.1 out of 5 stars ★	$1,463
Progressive	4.1 out of 5 stars ★	$1,758
Allstate	4 out of 5 stars ★	$1,974
Safeco	4 out of 5 stars ★	$1,405
Erie	3.9 out of 5 stars ★	$1,139
Farmers	3.9 out of 5 stars ★	$1,934
State Farm	3.8 out of 5 stars ★	$1,383

Collapse table

→ Learn more about our picks for the best car insurance companies

The latest research & surveys from Policygenius

The Best and Worst States to Own an Electric Vehicle

California topped our list of best states for EV owners thanks to widely-available charging and robust laws supporting electric vehicle ownership.

Read the full report

Road Rage Survey

46% of Americans said they believe angry driving has happened more frequently since the start of the pandemic.

Read the full report

The Best & Worst Cities for Car Theft

In some U.S. cities, 2020 was the biggest year for car thefts in decades, and the Denver-Aurora-Lakewood area was the worst area in the U.S. when it came to auto theft.

Read the full report

Compare auto insurance guide

• Why you should compare auto insurance quotes

• Here's what determines your car insurance rates

• How to compare car insurance quotes

Why you should compare auto insurance quotes

Policygenius customers saved an average of $435 a year on car insurance by comparing quotes. Rates vary by company, even for the same driver, so comparing options means you can be sure you’re getting the best deal possible.

Policygenius can show you quotes from top companies, so you can pick the one that offers you the best rates.

When you get quotes, you’ll find that your auto insurance rates are based on lots of factors, like your coverage limits, age, location, driving history, and more.

Here’s what determines your car insurance rates:

• Your address: Accident rates, population density, and repair costs in your neighborhood will all go into calculating your premiums.

• Your coverage: More types of coverage and higher limits means more protection, but it also means higher premiums.

• Your age: Younger, less experienced drivers (under 25) are more likely to get in accidents and file claims, so they often pay the most for car insurance.

• Your car: The make and model of car you drive will affect your insurance rates. Luxury cars with expensive parts cost more to insure than a budget daily driver, and cars with certain safety features can get you a lower rate.

• Your credit score: Drivers with poor credit scores may have more trouble finding affordable coverage than drivers with higher credit scores.

• Your driving history: Recent accidents and driving violations will raise a red flag on your profile, while having a squeaky clean record can earn you extra savings.

• Your insurance history: Recent claims on your record or gaps where you were uninsured will mean higher rates.

How to compare car insurance quotes

Auto insurance quotes are free — you don’t pay for anything until you actually get a policy — so it’s always worth it to get quotes from at least a few different insurance companies before you decide. Here’s how to comparison shop for car insurance:

1. Figure out how much coverage you need

Most drivers should get a full-coverage policy, which means one that includes comprehensive and collision coverage (that’s what covers damage to your own car). 

Comprehensive and collision coverage both require that you choose a deductible amount, which is what you agree to pay out of pocket per-claim. Car insurance deductibles are usually set at $500 or $1,000 — the higher you set your deductible, the lower your rates will be. Just remember that you’ll actually have to pay that amount yourself if you need to use that coverage. 

You’ll also need to choose liability coverage levels. That’s the part of your car insurance that covers the damage when you’re at fault in an accident. Liability coverage is the backbone of your car insurance policy, and we recommend setting high limits so you’ll be fully covered, even in a worst-case scenario. Here’s a good place to start:

Liability limits are usually written out with slashes, so those coverage amounts might be listed as 100/300/100 in your policy.

Remember, if you don’t have enough liability coverage, you’ll be on the hook for any medical bills or damage that exceeds your policy limits, and your assets (like your home or savings) could be at risk.

2. Set a budget

Once understand how different types of car insurance work and you know how much coverage you need, set a reasonable monthly or annual budget.  Check out average rates for drivers in your area to get a sense of how much you’ll pay for the coverage you need. 

Remember, factors like where you live, your age, your driving record, and your credit score can all affect your car insurance quotes. While your rates may be higher or lower than average, it’s still good to know what to expect so you can tell when quotes are too high.

3. Fill out an application

Because car insurance quotes are based on your personal information, there’s no way to get a reliable quote without sharing at least a little bit about yourself. 

Companies use your personal details to calculate how much you’ll pay for car insurance, so before you sit down to shop, gather up the following information:

• Names, birthdays and driver’s license numbers for everyone in your home who’s of driving age

• Social Security numbers for all drivers in the household

• VINs (Vehicle Information Numbers) or make and model years for every car you need to insure

• Your address (you’ll have to list both where you live and where the car is garaged, which is usually the same place)

• A little bit about your driving history, including recent accidents or violations 

• Your declarations page from your last or current car insurance policy, if you have it

• Personal details, like whether or not you’re married, what your job is, and whether you rent or own your home

It’s important to be honest during the car insurance application process. If you change or omit any of your information, you won’t get accurate quotes, and you may wind up having to pay more once you get the actual policy.

4. Take a look at your quotes

Once you’ve gotten car insurance quotes from at least a few different companies, go through the offerings to make sure you’re comparing apples to apples. Are they all for the same term length — and do they all include the same add-ons? 

Some insurance companies may show you quotes with multiple coverage tiers, often you’ll see a bare-bones one with low limits, a medium tier, and a premium option with endorsements already added. 

Make sure you’re getting enough coverage to fully protect you in case of an accident, and nothing you don’t need. If you’re a member of AAA, for example, you don’t need to add roadside assistance to your car insurance policy too.

5. Choose a policy and get insured

Found the right option for you? Double check that it’s for the right coverage limits and term length, and that you understand what’s included in the policy.

Once you’re sure about your choice, sign your policy and set it to start the exact day you need it. Once you pay your first premium (sometimes referred to as a down payment), you’re good to go.

You’ll receive information about your new policy from the company, and you may also be invited to download and set-up a mobile app. Save any emails or letters you get at the start of your policy so you know exactly where to find information about it in case you need to file a claim later.

6. Cancel your old policy (if you have one)

As soon as your new policy is set up, you can cancel your old one. Canceling a car insurance policy is easy, and you can usually do it in one phone call (you may even be able to do it online). You don’t have to wait until the end of your policy term to cancel, you can do it at any time. 

And if you paid your entire annual premium in-full at the start of the policy and you’re canceling early, you’ll probably be refunded for the months you didn’t use (minus any fees).

Just make sure to set your old coverage to end on the same day your new policy starts, so you don’t have a lapse in coverage.

Average savings on auto insurance: Savings are determined by calculating the average difference between the lowest and second lowest auto insurance policy estimates provided to shoppers with two or more estimates between 06/01/2020 and 05/18/2021. Potential savings are based on a composite of multiple different contracts and insurers. Not all policies in this calculation are available in all states, and availability may be based on eligibility. Savings may vary by policy amount and location.