What are the best health insurance companies?

How to determine what the best health insurance company is for you.

Published September 11, 2019

info
Advertising Disclosure

The best health insurance company for you depends on two things: your budget and your preferences.

All health insurance companies (carriers) and plans are federally mandated by the Affordable Care Act to cover ten essential benefits, which include preventative care, emergency services, and hospitalization. All carriers and plans are also required to adhere to the same consumer protections, also laid out by the Affordable Care Act. This means that you can trust that each health insurance company is held to the same standard, making it much easier to compare on price and individual preference.

The best health insurance companies

NameFoundedSizeJD Power RatingA.M. Best RatingOur RatingOur Review
Kaiser1945Third largest in the US5 out of 5A-5 out of 5 (quality and satisfaction); 4 out of 5 (affordability)Kaiser Overview
Humana1961Fifth largest in the US4 out of 5A-3 out of 5 (quality and satisfaction); 4 out of 5 (affordability)Humana Overview
Blue Cross Blue Shield1929Largest in the US3 out of 5A-4 out of 5 (quality and satisfaction); 4 out of 5 (affordability)Blue Cross Blue Shield Overview
Aetna1853Fourth largest in the US2 out of 5A-3 out of 5 (quality and satisfaction); 4 out of 5 (affordability)Aetna Overview
Cigna1982Sixth largest in the US3 out of 5A3 out of 5 (quality and satisfaction); 3 out of 5 (affordability)Cigna Overview
UnitedJHealthcare1977Second largest in the US2 out of 5A3 out of 5 (quality and satisfaction); 3 out of 5 (affordability)UnitedHealthcare Overview
Oscar2013Ranking unknownNANANA (quality and satisfaction); 5 out of 5 (affordability)Oscar Overview

Choosing the best health insurance company

When comparing health insurance plans, many people look at the base monthly price only. This monthly cost, called the premium, only represents one of the expenses that contributes to how much you'll spend on health care in a given month.

policygeniusSymbolCenter

Get covered & save money this Open Enrollment.

Need health insurance for 2020? Find a plan that fits your needs, and let Policygenius find the discounts and subsidies you qualify for. Shop online today to get covered.

Other expenses, like your health insurance plan's deductible and the copay and coinsurance costs, directly contribute to how much you'll be spending overall on health care. Typically, a plan with a lower monthly premium will have a higher deductible, copay, and coinsurance percentage, which increases the amount you'll spend out-of-pocket for health care services.

When choosing a health insurance company, make sure to look closely at these costs. If you plan on utilizing your health insurance plan frequently – because you're managing a chronic condition or otherwise – the least expensive plan may not be the plan with the lowest monthly premium.

The other thing to consider when choosing a health insurance company and plan are your preferences when it comes to doctors and prescriptions. Are there certain doctors you want to make sure are in your plan's network? Particular prescriptions? Plans that cover doctors and prescriptions you need may be more valuable to you than plans that don't.

Policygenius’ editorial content is not written by an insurance agent. It’s intended for informational purposes and should not be considered legal or financial advice. Consult a professional to learn what financial products are right for you.