What is new car replacement insurance?

If your car is totaled, new car replacement insurance pays for a new one of a similar make and model.

Anna SwartzAndrew Hurst


Anna Swartz

Anna Swartz

Managing Editor & Auto Insurance Expert

Anna Swartz is a managing editor and auto insurance expert at Policygenius, where she oversees our car insurance coverage. Previously, she was a senior staff writer at Mic.com, as well as an associate writer at The Dodo.

&Andrew Hurst

Andrew Hurst

Senior Editor & Licensed Auto Insurance Expert

Andrew Hurst is a senior editor and a licensed auto insurance expert at Policygenius. His work has also been featured in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Forbes, USA Today, NPR, Mic, Insurance Business Magazine, ValuePenguin, and Property Casualty 360.

Updated|5 min read

Policygenius content follows strict guidelines for editorial accuracy and integrity. Learn about our editorial standards and how we make money.

New car replacement is a coverage add-on that pays to replace your totaled car for a new vehicle that’s the same make and model. When your car is totaled, a standard full-coverage policy will be pay out for the car’s value minus aging and wear and tear. New car replacement insurance covers the entire cost of your car, so you can buy a brand new one.

Compare rates and shop affordable car insurance today

We don't sell your information to third parties.

You can only add the coverage to your car insurance policy if your vehicle is a newer model and if you’re the first owner, though each company has different rules. Typically the cost to add new car replacement varies by company, but it can be as low as $20 per six-month period.

Key takeaways

  • If your car is totaled, new car replacement coverage insurance pays to replace your totaled vehicle with one that’s the same make and model.

  • A full-coverage car insurance policy still pays for damage to your new car, but new car replacement coverage will pay for the entire cost of replacing your totaled vehicle.

  • You can usually only get new car replacement coverage for vehicles that are two years old or younger and that have been driven only a certain number of miles.

What is new car replacement insurance?

New car replacement insurance pays for the entire cost of a brand new vehicle of the same make and model if yours is totaled in an accident. Without new car replacement, your insurance company will pay for your car’s damage on an actual cash value basis.

That means that when your vehicle is totaled in an accident and you don’t have new car replacement coverage, you’ll receive a payout for the cost to replace your totaled car, minus the value it lost through normal aging and wear and tear (also called a car’s depreciation). The payout may not be enough to buy a brand new car of the same type, so you’d have to make up the difference yourself.

Type of coverageAmount covered
Full-coverage policyActual cash value (minus deductible)
Full coverage with new car replacementFull amount (minus deductible)

The cost of new car replacement depends on the company and your vehicle — it’s more expensive to get new car replacement for a luxury or high-tech car than for one that’s cheaper to replace. But you may be able to add new car replacement to your policy for as low as $20 per sixth-month period, or more depending on your insurer.

New car replacement vs. gap insurance

New car replacement coverage is similar to gap insurance, but they aren’t the same thing. Gap insurance is for drivers who are leasing or financing their car with a loan. Like new car replacement coverage, gap insurance acts as a guard against your car’s depreciation.

As your car loses its value, it can become worth less than the lease or loan . If your car were totaled, you’d have to pay the difference between the value of your car and the loan or lease. Instead, gap insurance pays the rest of the lease or loan, leaving you off the hook for the remaining payments. While gap insurance pays out your lessor or lienholder, new car replacement pays you.

You can get both new car replacement and gap coverage for a vehicle that you’re financing. If you’re leasing your car, you may need to get new car replacement along with gap insurance. Some companies don’t allow you to get gap insurance without buying new car replacement too.

→ Learn more about what gap insurance is and who needs it

Compare rates and shop affordable car insurance today

We don't sell your information to third parties.

How does new car replacement insurance work?

To use your new car replacement insurance, your vehicle must be a total loss. An insurance company declares a car a total loss when the cost to repair the damage is already close to or more than the car’s value, when the car is stolen, or when its damage is greater than a certain percentage of the vehicle’s pre-accident value.

When you make a claim for a covered loss, your new car replacement coverage will pay for the cost of a new car without considering your old car’s depreciation.

Let’s say you total your $20,000 car. In the year you’ve had it, the car’s value has dropped by 25%, or $5,000. Without new car replacement, you’d have to pay that $5,000 yourself if you wanted to replace your car with the same model, but with new car replacement coverage your insurance company would pay for the full value of a new car.

Who can get car replacement insurance?

New car replacement insurance isn’t available to everyone. Before you can get auto replacement protection, companies usually require that:

  • You are the car’s first owner

  • The car is only five or fewer model years old

  • There are fewer than 25,000 miles on the car’s odometer

Assuming your car meets these requirements, you must also have full-coverage auto coverage — meaning you have comprehensive and collision coverage — before you’ll be able add new car replacement insurance to a policy.

Do you need new car replacement insurance?

It could be a good idea to consider adding new car replacement coverage if your vehicle is eligible and you can find cheap quotes. However, because adding the coverage might be expensive depending on the car and company, it all comes down to your tolerance for risk.

Imagine that it costs $20 per month more to add new car replacement coverage to your car insurance. Most companies only offer new car replacement for cars two model years old or younger. That means that over two years you’d pay $480 per year. 

On the one hand, by paying more to add new car replacement coverage, you could avoid paying hundreds or thousands of dollars to make up for a totaled vehicle’s depreciation in the event of an accident. 

But if you’re not worried about replacing your car with a brand new version of the same car — or you’re comfortable paying for the cost of the vehicle’s depreciation yourself if an accident occurred — then you could avoid adding the coverage and raising your rates.  

Which companies have new car replacement insurance?

Many of the top car insurance companies offer new car replacement coverage, though each company has its own rules for which types of cars can get covered. You can’t get new car replacement from the largest companies if your car is older than 5 years or it has more than 24,000 miles on it.

Erie and Liberty Mutual both offer an enhanced form of new car replacement that allows drivers to get a newer car than their old one after an accident. This coverage is called Better Car Replacement with Liberty Mutual, and Auto Security with Erie.

AllstatePays for the cost to replace a totaled car as long as the vehicle is two years old or newer.
ErieReplaces a car that's two years old or newer
Farmers InsuranceAvailable to cars that are two model years old or newer and with 24,000 miles or fewer.
Liberty MutualApplies to vehicles in their first year of ownership or within their first 15,000 miles.
NationwidePays to replace a totaled car that's two years old or newer.
TravelersReplaces a totaled car that's five model years old or newer as long as you're the original owner.
USAAAdds an additional 20% to the actual cash value of the vehicle.

Compare rates and shop affordable car insurance today

We don't sell your information to third parties.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is new car replacement insurance worth it?

New car replacement insurance is worth getting if you have a new, expensive car and you can find a company that offers affordable coverage. The cost of adding new car replacement coverage to a policy is likely to be less expensive than a vehicle’s depreciation over time, but the coverage only kicks in if you total your car, which means you might wind up paying for a coverage you never need to use.

What is vehicle replacement insurance?

Vehicle replacement insurance is another name for new car replacement coverage. Vehicle replacement insurance covers new vehicles (usually two model years old or younger). After a covered vehicle is totaled, the insurance company pays to replace the car without factoring in its depreciation.

Who has new car replacement coverage?

Not every company offers new car replacement coverage. However, drivers can find new car replacement coverage from well-known insurance companies like Allstate, Erie, Farmers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Travelers, and USAA.

How does insurance change when you get a new car?

When you get a new car, your insurance coverage applies to the new vehicle. Companies give drivers grace periods for new vehicles, but eventually they require new vehicles to be reported officially.