It's usually not possible to insure a car you don't own, because you don't have what's typically called "insurable interest" in the car
One alternate option is to co-title the car and add yourself as an owner
You can also look into non-owner insurance, which will cover you for liability while driving a car that isn't yours
It’s not a common scenario, but there are some reasons why you might want to insure a car you don’t actually own — maybe it belongs to a family member, but you’re the only one driving it. Generally, whoever is the titled owner of a car needs to be the one to insure it. Car insurance companies want to make sure the primary policyholder has what’s called insurable interest in the car they’re insuring.
Insurable interest essentially means you have a reason to insure a vehicle. If you’re the car’s owner, the reason is self-evident: The car is your investment, so you have a stake in keeping it from being damaged or destroyed.
Ready to shop car insurance?
Get auto quotes
But it’s harder to prove your insurable interest if you don’t actually own a vehicle. When you’re trying to insure a vehicle you don’t own, car insurance companies will be wary of fraud, and be far less likely to allow you to take out a policy. But, while opening a policy on a car that you don’t own is rare, that doesn’t mean you don’t have options.
In order to apply for a car insurance policy, you may need to show something that proves your insurable interest, like your car’s registration or your car’s title, also called a pink slip, which is an official document that says who owns a vehicle.
But if you don’t own a car, then it’s harder to prove to an insurance provider that you have a legitimate reason to insure it. Barring exceptional cases, it may not be possible for you to insure a car you don’t own. But one alternate option is to become an additional owner of the car by co-titling the vehicle.
Co-titling a vehicle means you’re adding an additional owner to a car. Each state’s Department of Motor Vehicles has specific requirements for doing this, but in order to add an owner to a car, you’ll likely need to jointly apply for a new title.
This usually involves filling out a form with the names and information of both drivers who will be listed on the title, paying a fee, and going to the DMV in person to sign the new title. If the car in question was purchased with a loan that hasn’t been fully paid off, then you’ll need to notify the lienholder and see if it’s possible to add an additional owner to the title.
But once you’re added to the title as a co-owner of a car, you’re free to get an insurance policy on that vehicle. As an owner, you can be the primary policyholder. But any other owner should also be listed on the car insurance policy.
Get a non-owner’s policy, because you don’t own the car.
While you may not be able to insure a car you don’t own, if you’d like to protect yourself as a driver you can look into something called non-owner car insurance. Ideal for drivers who frequently rent or borrow cars, non-owner insurance is a kind of pared-down car insurance policy.
Policygenius home and auto expert Fabio Faschi suggests that anyone trying to figure out how to insure a car they don't own should get non-owner insurance instead. "Get a non-owner’s policy, because you don’t own the car," Faschi said. "We’d want to cover you for liability, but the vehicle itself has to be insured by the owner."
Non-owner insurance often just includes liability coverage, the backbone of most insurance policies. You can sometimes add personal injury protection, which covers your own medical expenses if you cause an accident, or uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, which covers you if you’re in an accident caused by a driver without insurance, or whose insurance won’t cover the full extent of the damage.
But non-owner insurance doesn’t include the kind of coverage that’s designed to protect your vehicle, like collision and comprehensive coverage, because there’s no vehicle to protect. Still, if you find yourself frequently driving a car that doesn’t belong to you, getting non-owner insurance may be a more realistic option than trying to get a car insurance policy for a car that’s not in your name.
Anna Swartz is a Managing Editor at Policygenius, where she has been since 2018. An expert in home, auto and renters insurance, she loves making tough concepts easy to understand and helping readers feel confident about their insurance options. Before joining Policygenius, she was a senior staff writer at Mic. Her work has appeared in The Dodo, AOL, HuffPost, Salon and Heeb.
Fabio Faschi is the property and casualty team lead at Policygenius in New York City. He's worked in the insurance and real estate industry for more than six years as an independent agent and broker representing more than 40 carriers in property and casualty products, and previously worked in real estate settlements and title insurance negotiating insurance requirements with banks, realtors, and new home buyers. Fabio's expertise on home & auto insurance has been featured on Forbes, Consumer Affairs, Realtor.com, Apartment Therapy, The Simple Dollar, SFGATE, Bankrate, and Lifehacker.
Education & Certifications
Fabio has a bachelor's degree from Seton Hall University. He is a certified Personal Lines Coverage Specialist (PLCS), Small Business Coverage Specialist (SBCS), and Commercial Lines Coverage Specialist (CLCS).
Was this article helpful?