Is mortgage protection insurance worth it?

Share
More
Is mortgage protection insurance worth it?

Life insurance is the ultimate financial safety net. No matter what your plans and goals in life — retire, pay off your student loan debt, put your kids through college without them racking up their own debt — life insurance allows your family to reach those goals in the event that you die.
Another big financial commitment? Buying a house.

A home is one of the biggest purchases — and largest sources of debt — that a person can have. That’s why mortgage protection insurance can seem so appealing. An insurance product specifically made to address your monthly mortgage payment? Sounds great.

But before you start digging into mortgage protection insurance quotes, you should know why it’s not the best life insurance option for most shoppers.

What is mortgage protection insurance?

Mortgage protection life insurance is basically what it sounds like: life insurance that’s designed to protect your family from burdensome mortgage payments if the primary breadwinner isn’t around to provide an income any longer.

Mortgage insurance is broadly similar to other types of term life insurance in how it works. You buy a policy, pay regular premiums, and, at the end of the policy term, it ends. If you die during the term of the policy, a death benefit is paid out to your beneficiaries.

However, mortgage protection insurance has a few key differences.

First, the mortgage company or lender is usually the beneficiary in a mortgage protection insurance policy. That means the death benefit bypasses your family and goes straight to the lender to pay off the mortgage.

And speaking of the death benefit, because it’s used to pay off your mortgage balance in most cases, it usually decreases after the first five years of coverage to match your remaining mortgage. This is unlike other term life insurance policies, where the death benefit stays constant unless you make changes to the policy.

Finally, the term lengths for term life insurance policies is usually fairly flexible; you can usually choose term lengths in five- or ten-year intervals, and some carriers even allow custom term lengths. However, mortgage protection insurance is usually locked in, usually at 15 years or 30 years. Your term length may also be limited by your age; for instance, State Farm’s mortgage protection insurance limits you to a 15-year term if you’re above age 45.

What’s good about mortgage protection insurance?

Mortgage protection insurance highlights one of the biggest debts a person can have, and earmarks money specifically for it. If your family receives a lump sum of money, it can be overwhelming knowing how to allocate it appropriately.

Mortgage protection insurance takes the guesswork out of it. Because it’s matched up to the mortgage balance, and the money will go only toward that, there’s no worrying that there won’t be enough to cover the remaining mortgage.

It also has the benefit of allowing the policyholder to potentially avoid the underwriting process. Since life insurance rates are largely determined by the health of the applicant, this results in higher premiums, but it can be worthwhile if poor health would raise the premiums of a standard term life insurance policy even more.

What’s bad about mortgage protection insurance?

The main drawback of a mortgage protection insurance policy is its narrow scope. Being able to cover mortgage payments is great, but you’re doing so at the expense of your family’s other debts and bills. A regular term life insurance policy allows you to cover your mortgage and then some.

For anyone looking for the most affordable term life insurance options, mortgage protection insurance isn’t your best bet. It’s more expensive than a standard term life insurance policy; a $250,000, 30-year term mortgage protection insurance policy through State Farm, for an applicant in excellent health, is more than double a comparable term life insurance policy.

The decreasing death benefit amount is also a limiting factor. Because the death benefit is matched to your mortgage balance, it doesn’t give you much flexibility if things change in your life. Worse, policies are usually level premium, meaning that, as time goes on, you’re literally paying the same for less.

And the lack of flexibility doesn’t end there. The coverage amounts, limited terms, and potential age restrictions all contribute to a strict policy that doesn’t take into account the numerous changes you and your family will go through during the course of the policy. Overall, tmortgage protection insurance's cost isn't worth the relatively limited protection.

Alternatives to mortgage protection insurance

The most popular – and best – alternative to mortgage protection insurance is a standard term life insurance policy. It’s like a mortgage protection insurance policy in that you pay for the policy for a certain amount of time, but it doesn’t come with all of the strings that mortgage protection insurance does.

Term life insurance provides your beneficiaries (who can be your family, other loved ones, or even institutions) a tax-free, lump sum amount of cash that they can use for whatever they need. That might be paying off a mortgage, but it could also mean other loans, saving for retirement and college, or just paying day-to-day bills to help make ends meet.

Other types of permanent life insurance are also alternatives; they last for the policyholder’s entire life, as long as premiums are paid, rather than expiring. However, permanent life insurance policies are more expensive than mortgage protection insurance policies, and much more expensive than a standard term life insurance policy, and are typically more complicated than what the average person needs for their financial safety net.

Is mortgage protection insurance worth it?

If you’ll be unable to get a competitive life insurance rate due to health issues, a mortgage protection insurance policy may help. We’ve advocated for other no medical exam policies in the past for similar special circumstances. But look into mortgage protection insurance companies before signing up with your mortgage lender right away to make sure you're getting the best deal.

However, for most people who need life insurance to cover more than just their mortgage – which is most people – a standard term life insurance policy is the better option. It’s more affordable, provides more protection, and allows for more flexibility. And even if you think an affordable policy is out of reach because of your health, it’s worth getting a free quote because you’ll probably be surprised at how competitive your standard term life insurance rates can be. Compare quotes tailored to you in just minutes with our free shopping tool.

Updated Nov 13, 2017