Is Credit Karma the right choice for tracking your credit?


Jill Jaracz

Jill Jaracz

Blog author Jill Jaracz

Jill Jaracz is a freelance writer covering a variety of topics including credit cards and personal branding. Her work has been featured on and in leading B2B publications. She also hosts and produces Olympic Fever, the podcast for fans of the Olympics. Check out her work at and follow her on Twitter @jilljaracz.

Published August 14, 2019 | 4 min read

Policygenius content follows strict guidelines for editorial accuracy and integrity. Learn about our editorial standards and how we make money.

News article image

Over the last few years, I’ve seen a lot of advertising about the importance of knowing your credit score — and it’s true. Your credit score can help you qualify for a loan, get better credit cards, and receive cheaper insurance, among other things.

Credit Karma is a company that capitalizes on that three-digit number — they use your credit score to make product recommendations that can save you money. I decided to give Credit Karma a spin and see if it’s really a must-have app.

The Good

  • Instant access to your credit score and credit report

  • Access to your auto insurance score

  • Identity monitoring

  • Library of financial literacy articles

The Bad

  • VantageScore 3.0 isn’t the only scoring model

  • Doesn’t include one credit bureau

  • Lots of product selling

What is Credit Karma & how does it work

Credit Karma is designed to help you understand personal finance. Its focal point is your credit score, a fluctuating three-digit number ranging from 300 to 850 that helps lenders determine how much money they should lend you and what interest rate to charge you. This number is based on a number of inputs including:

  • Number of credit accounts

  • On-time bill payment

  • Percentage of credit limit used

  • Account longevity

  • Dings such as collections, tax liens, bankruptcies or civil judgment

  • Frequency of credit applications

The higher your credit score, the more likely you’ll be able to get credit and the better the terms will be.

Credit Karma’s dashboard credit scores come from Transunion and Equifax. You can drill down on each score to see how you stack up in all of the factors and learn where you can improve. You can also access your credit report.

Other app features include:

  • Auto insurance scores

  • Identity monitoring

  • Unclaimed property searches

  • Financial education articles

  • Offers for credit cards and loans

What’s good about Credit Karma?

Instant access to your credit score and credit report If you need quick access to your credit score and a brief credit report, Credit Karma is the right place to go. It also looks at how your spending behavior affects the different factors that go into creating your credit score, which gives you better insight on how to make improvements. (Here's how to read a credit report.)

Access to your auto insurance score The auto section is a really nice feature. It provides your insurance score, a number similar to your credit score that auto insurers may use to determine rates. Adding a car make and model lets you see its current value and whether it has any recalls.

For other types of insurance, like life insurance, you'll have to go through an application process to get your rating.

Identity monitoring Major information breaches are commonplace these days. Credit Karma will give you a heads up if your email address or account passwords are on the dark web. You’ll have the chance to change your information — hopefully before the worst happens.

Financial literacy articles Credit Karma does provide a lot of useful basic financial information that can make you smarter about personal finance.

What’s bad about Credit Karma?

VantageScore 3.0 isn’t the only scoring model The scoring model Credit Karma uses is just one of several in existence. If you’re hinging your financial future on Credit Karma’s numbers and apply for a loan or credit card with a bank that uses a different model, like a FICO score, you may not get the lending terms you expect.

Doesn’t include one credit bureau There are three major credit bureaus, but Credit Karma doesn’t include Experian’s data. This means you won’t necessarily get a full picture of your credit history and score, as each credit bureau calculates them a little differently.

Lots of product selling Credit Karma prides itself on being free, but it takes money to run the company. How do they do it? By referring credit card and loan applications. One of the most prominent things on my dashboard is an application for a credit card, and most sections have some sort of financial product to push. It’s an annoying necessity that can be a quick turn-off, particularly if you have a poor credit score.

Here are some simple ways to improve your credit in 30 days.

Is Credit Karma worth it?

It’s easy to get fixated on credit scores because it provides some insight into the health of your financial life. But if you’re not planning to borrow money anytime soon or don’t need to repair your credit, it’s may be pointless to have an app to continually monitor your credit score.

Want to learn your credit score? Several banks and credit card companies provide that information free of charge, and by law you’re entitled to a free credit report from each of the credit bureaus once a year, which can help you keep tabs on your data.

While the app does conveniently draw together some interesting financial information into one place, the constant product selling can make it difficult to discern what’s useful information and what’s an advertisement.

Image: Webaroo